Each year, all eyes turn to Broadway as the Tony Awards take center stage. The highest honor in New York theatre, the Tonys recognize standout productions, performances, and creative teams that keep the city buzzing. For visitors, a nomination or win isn’t just prestige—it’s a guide to this season’s must-see shows.
Musicals and plays recognized by the Tonys quickly rise to the top of every theatre fan’s list, making them essential stops for anyone planning a New York trip. With the 2025–2026 season underway, excitement is building around the next wave of Tony hopefuls—from bold new musicals to revivals starring Broadway favorites. The Broadway Collection tracks these developments, highlighting shows with both award buzz and unforgettable performances.
Planning ahead means securing the best seats for productions that could define Broadway’s newest era. As the Tonys set the stage, your next unforgettable night on Broadway might be just around the corner.
________________________________________
Revivals You’ll Want to See
Chess
Chess first made its mark on Broadway in 1988, and although its original run was brief, the show won over musical theatre fans with its sweeping score. Lyrics by Tim Rice and music from Benny Andersson and Björn Ulvaeus (of ABBA fame) have helped Chess maintain cult favorite status for decades. The plot, unfolding against the drama of the Cold War, centers on the high-stakes rivalry between an American and a Russian grandmaster, with plenty of personal intrigue added in.
Now, Chess is back on Broadway, complete with a standout cast including previous Tony winner Aaron Tveit, Lea Michele (a familiar face from stage and screen), and powerhouse vocalist Nicholas Christopher. This revival brings the tension, emotion, and bold music to a new generation of theatregoers. With its intense storytelling and rich musical moments, Chess is primed for renewed attention—expect audiences to be drawn in by both the show’s political drama and the sheer vocal power on display. This return has all the makings of a show that could generate plenty of Tony buzz all over again.
CATS: The Jellicle Ball
Back in 1982, Cats exploded onto Broadway, enchanting audiences with Andrew Lloyd Webber’s unforgettable score and lyrics inspired by T. S. Eliot’s famous collection of cat poems. The original production swept up seven Tony Awards and quickly became a theatre phenomenon, remembered for its remarkable mix of catchy music and dynamic choreography. After an impressive 18-year run and a previous revival, Broadway is welcoming a fresh version for 2026—CATS: The Jellicle Ball.
This newest production dives into the sparkling world of ballroom culture, setting the action amid the glitz, energy, and expressive artistry made famous by New York’s ballroom scene. Expect high-octane voguing, standout performances, and a bold visual style that celebrates love, identity, and belonging. Audiences will find all the songs they know and love—plus the pulse and spectacle of ballroom added to the mix. It’s a one-of-a-kind experience that shines a spotlight on the power and resilience within the LGBTQIA+ community, making this Cats both a return to Broadway and an all-new celebration of performance and unity.
New Arrivals This Season
The Lost Boys
The iconic world of The Lost Boys comes to the stage for the first time, reimagining the beloved ‘80s vampire film as a thrilling live musical. Set in the fictional, sun-drenched town of Santa Carla, the show features a pulsating rock score by indie band The Rescues, capturing the story’s rebellious energy and sense of danger. It follows teenage brothers Michael and Sam as they navigate new friendships, family ties, and the seductive pull of a hidden underworld.
Visually stunning scenes (and high-flying stunts!) come to life through the work of the Tony-winning team behind last season's Best Musical Maybe Happy Ending, with direction by Michael Arden and scenic and video design by Dane Laffrey. Led by Tony nominees Ali Louis Bourzgui and Shoshana Bean, the cast brings big vocals and star energy to this haunting tale. Whether you're a longtime fan or new to the story, The Lost Boys promises an electrifying theatrical experience.
Two Strangers (Carry a Cake Across New York)
Two Strangers (Carry a Cake Across New York) has made the leap from London’s West End and the American Repertory Theater to a celebrated Broadway run. This musical comedy introduces us to Dougal—a cheerful Brit arriving in New York for his estranged father’s wedding, seeing the city for the first time. Helping him navigate the chaos is Robin, the bride’s overextended sister, who ends up tasked with shepherding both Dougal and a delicate wedding cake from the airport across Manhattan.
What starts as a simple mission becomes an unpredictable trek through the city—filled with mishaps, sharp banter, and unexpected heart. As Dougal and Robin navigate city streets and emotional detours, the show blends laugh-out-loud comedy with moments that reveal second chances and the possibility of connection.
Classics and Long-Running Contenders
Broadway sparkles with a blend of bold new shows and timeless hits that have become legendary. Every season offers fresh thrills, yet the long-running musicals keep drawing audiences and shaping the vibrant energy of the Theatre District. Here’s a look at some of the standout Tony-winning shows still lighting up Broadway:
- The Book of Mormon — A witty, uproarious musical still winning over audiences with its sharp humor and catchy songs.
- Hamilton — Lin-Manuel Miranda’s dynamic retelling of American history remains a must-see with its popular hip-hop score and storytelling.
- Hadestown — The journey of Orpheus and Eurydice comes to life in a production full of New Orleans-inspired music and imaginative staging.
- The Lion King — Disney’s beloved classic delivers a visual spectacle that delights visitors of all ages.
- Maybe Happy Ending — A unique, heartfelt exploration of love and technology in future Seoul, known for touching performances.
- Moulin Rouge! The Musical — A high-energy celebration of love and Parisian nightlife, set to a pop-infused soundtrack.
- The Outsiders — S.E. Hinton’s familiar story finds new life with moving performances and a thrilling rumble.
Whether you’re hunting for the next breakout hit or revisiting a beloved favorite, these shows are must-see Broadway experiences. With Tony buzz surrounding this season’s top contenders, seeing a production at its peak adds an extra spark to your visit. Check out The Broadway Collection to learn more about these shows—and plenty of other can’t-miss productions—so you can plan your New York City theatre adventure and soak in the excitement of Broadway at its finest.