Choosing the perfect Broadway show can feel like putting together the ultimate playlist: it needs to vibe with your interests, fit the length of your stay, and match your theatre experience level. Whether you're in town for a quick theatre binge or you're a local looking for a weekend escape, knowing your style is crucial. Are you into the kind of stories that tug at your heartstrings, or are you seeking something that’ll have you rolling in the aisles? And if you're a Broadway newbie, why not dive into something that’ll leave you spellbound? More seasoned theatre-goers might appreciate something off the beaten path. No matter your vibe, New York's stages have a show for you.
Check out our show guide below, with suggestions catered to your unique style—whether you're looking to match your interests, fit the length of your stay, or delve into a theatrical experience that’s just right. Our guide will help you find the perfect show to make your Broadway experience unforgettable, no matter where you fall on the theatre spectrum.
Broadway Picks for Every Passion
With Broadway's diverse range of productions, there's something for everyone, wherever your interests lie. If you're fascinated by history, love a good comedy, or are drawn to magical fantasy worlds, there's a show that’s perfect for you on the vibrant stages of New York City.
For the History Buff:
For the history enthusiast seeking a Broadway experience, Hamilton and SIX provide dynamic and enlightening takes on historical narratives. Hamilton offers a revolutionary look at the life of one of America's Founding Fathers, Alexander Hamilton, through a vibrant mix of hip-hop, jazz, and traditional musical theatre. Its portrayal of resilience and ambition in the face of adversity is both educational and inspirational, making it a must-watch for anyone fascinated by American history. Meanwhile, SIX brings to life the stories of the six wives of Henry VIII, reimagined as pop divas in this empowering musical. The show infuses their historical tales with contemporary pop music, offering a modern, feminist reimagining of these powerful figures. Both shows not only educate but also captivate with their unique storytelling and striking musical scores.
For the Cinephile:
For the movie lover eager to witness captivating stories from the big screen brought to life on stage, Broadway offers adaptations that retain all the charm and intrigue of their cinematic roots. Death Becomes Her is an exuberant new musical that translates the 1992 cult classic into a theatrical adventure about vanity, immortality, and the price of eternal youth. Packed with dazzling costumes, sharp-witted dialogue, and a hilariously clever plot, the show delivers standout performances and musical numbers that both spoof and celebrate classic Broadway—making it a perfect treat for fans of comedy, glamour, and high-energy entertainment.
For Fantasy and Sci-Fi Fanatics:
For fans of the fantastical, Broadway offers spellbinding productions that transport audiences to otherworldly realms. Harry Potter and the Cursed Child is a continuation of J.K. Rowling's magical series, wowing audiences with its breathtaking stagecraft and intricate plot twists. The show takes audiences back to Hogwarts, following Harry, his friends, and their children on a new adventure that delves into themes of friendship, family, and legacy. Meanwhile, Stranger Things: The First Shadow brings the thrilling energy of Hawkins, Indiana, to the stage, capturing the nostalgic pulse of the hit series while introducing new layers to its mysterious supernatural world. With a gripping storyline and familiar yet fresh characters, this production promises to enchant all audiences, even if they're not versed in the Netflix show. Both productions weave extraordinary narratives with stunning visuals, offering fans of fantasy an unforgettable theatrical journey.
Broadway Picks for Every Stage of the Journey
When choosing a Broadway show, consider your level of familiarity with theatre to find a production that suits your experience. From newcomers discovering the magic of live theatre to seasoned Broadway enthusiasts seeking fresh excitement, a perfect show awaits to match your taste. Taking into account your previous experiences can help enhance your enjoyment, allowing you to find productions that meet your expectations while also expanding your theatrical horizons.
For the Newcomer:
If you're just starting your Broadway journey, exploring classic musicals is a fantastic way to dive into the magic of theatre. Chicago, with its dazzling 1920s setting, captivating characters, and sultry numbers like "Cell Block Tango," offers newcomers a taste of Broadway style. This production's blend of intrigue, humor, and show-stopping choreography makes it a timeless hit, perfect for those getting their first taste of musical theatre.
Familiarity with an artist's music can serve as an inviting entry point into the world of Broadway, making the transition to live theatre both exciting and comforting. If you're already a fan of a particular artist's work, experiencing their music in a Broadway setting can bring a new dimension to your appreciation.
MJ is a vibrant musical that celebrates the legendary career of Michael Jackson. Through his catalogue of hits and electrifying dance routines, this show gives fans an intimate peek into the world of the King of Pop, seamlessly blending his iconic music with Broadway magic. Similarly, Mamma Mia! is a jubilant homage to the music of ABBA, intertwining their timeless songs like "Dancing Queen" and "Mamma Mia" into a heartfelt, comedic narrative. This show provides a joyous and familiar experience for those who love the Swedish pop group's classics, offering both emotional resonance and feel-good entertainment. For newcomers, these productions make for an inviting and memorable introduction to Broadway.
For the Seasoned Theatregoer:
For the Broadway veteran, finding fresh experiences and revisiting classic narratives with a new twist is key to keeping the Broadway magic alive. With a rich understanding of the stage, you'll appreciate the nuances of innovative storytelling and standout performances that push the boundaries of theatre.
One such transformative experience is the 2024 revival of Gypsy, featuring the incomparable Audra McDonald as Mama Rose. Known for her extraordinary range and record-breaking six Tony Awards, McDonald brings new depth and charisma to this defining role. Her portrayal elevates the timeless story of ambition and showbiz, creating a performance that's both familiar and refreshingly insightful. With McDonald at the helm, this retelling of Gypsy promises to resonate with Broadway fans, offering a nuanced exploration of maternal love and the pursuit of the American dream, all under the visionary direction of George C. Wolfe.
In addition to revisiting classics, exploring new hits can offer thrilling discoveries. Consider diving into the Olivier-winning transfer from the West End, Operation Mincemeat. This production brings a fresh twist to Broadway with its witty, fast-paced narrative that combines elements of Singin' in the Rain with Strangers on a Train. Set in 1943 during World War II, the musical tells the unbelievable true story of a twisted secret mission involving a stolen corpse that altered the course of history. With its blend of humor, historical intrigue, and inventive storytelling, Operation Mincemeat exemplifies the dynamic creativity of contemporary Broadway, offering seasoned theatregoers a distinctive theatrical event that enriches their ongoing appreciation for the stage.
Broadway Picks for Every Itinerary
When choosing a Broadway show based on the length of your trip, it's essential to consider how much time you have available and how integral theatre is to your travel itinerary. From a whirlwind weekend to a leisurely week-long stay, there's a perfect strategy to optimize your Broadway experience.
For the Weekend:
For shorter trips or first-time visits, prioritizing one or two must-see shows can provide a fulfilling experience without overwhelming your schedule. Renowned productions like The Lion King or The Book of Mormon often top the list for their universal appeal and impressive stagecraft. Additionally, Death Becomes Her, Best Musical Tony Award winner Maybe Happy Ending, and Buena Vista Social Club are must-sees this season. Focusing on these blockbuster titles ensures that you capture the essence of Broadway during your short stay.
For the Whole Week:
For a week-long trip, you'll have the opportunity to delve deeper into Broadway's eclectic offerings and expand your cultural experiences. This extended visit allows you to explore both the iconic hits and the more intimate or cutting-edge productions that showcase Broadway's vast creative spectrum.
Start your journey with Hadestown, a Tony Award-winning masterpiece that intertwines Greek mythology with contemporary issues, set to a mesmerizing score by singer-songwriter Anaïs Mitchell. This innovative musical delves into themes of love, sacrifice, and rebirth, combining stunning visuals with an evocative narrative. Then travel Off-Broadway for Little Shop of Horrors, a cult classic that never fails to thrill with its quirky charm and catchy tunes. This darkly comedic tale of an ambitious florist and a man-eating plant provides a delightful blend of humor and horror that will leave a lasting impression.
Between your Broadway adventures, venture to the Met Opera for an evening of grandeur and elegance. The world-class performances and breathtaking productions perfectly complement your itinerary, offering a broader artistic experience. With a week to explore, you can embrace the best of New York City’s vibrant cultural scene—from high-energy musicals to sophisticated opera—for a rich and unforgettable entertainment experience.
Ultimately, tailoring your show picks to the length and nature of your stay ensures that you optimize your time effectively, be it by soaking in the biggest hits or exploring a more eclectic mix of performances.
These are just a few approaches to help you choose the perfect Broadway show, whether you're planning your visit based on trip length, personal interests, or your experience with theatre. Each strategy can lead you to discover the best of Broadway, from long-standing classics to innovative new productions.
Explore the Broadway Collection pages for more on each show, including in-depth plot synopsis, show schedules and theatre information, and links to purchase tickets.